Secular Right | Reality & Reason

Mar/10

30

The unchurched president

Share on FacebookTweet about this on TwitterShare on RedditShare on StumbleUponEmail this to someoneShare on TumblrShare on Google+

Should Obama Attend Church?:

Tonight NBC Nightly News aired a clip from Matt Lauer’s interview with President Obama, in which he asked the President why he has not chosen a church to attend. He was told that so doing would create too much of a distraction for fellow parishioners, and that the President, instead, receives a daily “devotional” email from a group of pastors nationwide.

The author is a liberal mainstream Christian, not an evangelical. She seems concerned that Obama has not integrated himself into what liberals would call a “faith community,” as opposed to adhering to a specific religion which manifests exclusive Truth, as many conservative Christians might be. But the question itself is a sign of the influence of evangelical Protestantism on our public culture, where details of one’s religious stances are held up to scrutiny if one is a public figure. But America has a long, though one somewhat in disrepair of late, tradition of heads of state who have ambivalent or weak relationships to organized religion.

In any case, I assume most readers of this weblog don’t care one way or another. It’s just a commentary about our culture that this is even an issue when the current president has pushed the passage of the most significant legislation of the past generation, for good or ill. When it comes to political leaders I think this statement attributed to Confucius is appropriate:

We have not yet learned to know life. How can we know what comes after death? We do not yet know how to live. Do not trouble with another life before you know how to live a good life with men on earth. Live in one world at a time.

Our presidents are profane figures, not priest-kings. They have four to eight years to affect the present in profound ways, they can spent their retirement contemplating transcendence (as figures as disparate as Chandragupta Maurya and Lee Teng-hui have).

Note: A reasonable religious objection is that the god(s) will show favor to nations if the powers that be give them their due. The problem which this statement from a “rational” stance is which gods does one pray to? It may be that a stance of neutrality is more rational than picking a particular set of god(s) if those god(s) turn out to be false, and one ends up angering the real god(s). On the other hand, if the god(s) are indulgent then I think they would indulge presidents in focusing on matters of earthly import when they have so much power to wield.

3 comments

  • Polichinello · March 31, 2010 at 9:59 am

    In his defense, there’s really no church he could attend that wouldn’t get him in hot water. He can’t go back to the Chicken George act that is Rev. Wright. If he goes to some happy-clappy liberal church, their goofy, make-it-up-as-the-zeitgeist-changes theology will further energize the right. If he tries to attend some moderately conservative church, like Rick Warren’s Saddleback, his leftist base will go batsh*t insane.

    Too, I doubt Michelle is all that willing to give up on Trinity, so they’ll play coy for now. Once they’re back in Chicago, the Obama’s will start screaming “Amen” to Wright’s replacement’s next chorus of “GAWD DAMM UHMAIRIKAH!!!”

  • brandon · March 31, 2010 at 5:31 pm

    I really enjoyed your last paragraph, and to an atheist it just always seems absurd that grown men and women actually ponder these issues seriously.

    I mean really…churches? temples? worship? hocus pocus? This is the 21st century for crying out loud!

  • cynthia curran · March 31, 2010 at 6:10 pm

    Well, Warren’s church is too underrepresented of hispanics and asians. The real OC hardy had blacks about 2 percent but a lot more hispanics than most of the country around 33 percent hispanic and 16 percent asian but Rick’s church only look’s around about 5 percent hispanic, 5 percent asian and only 1 percent black. Most of the minorites in OC have there own churches and white’s have their’s. Another reason Obama would not attend Saddleback.

<<

>>

Theme Design by devolux.nh2.me